Altruism: The Comprehensive Single-Volume Reference CompassionSolution.Org Has Been Waiting For
Matthieu Ricard's 850-page treatment of altruism, compassion, and human flourishing is the most thorough single-author treatment of these topics currently in print. It is also the cleanest available bridge between rigorous science and contemplative tradition, written by an author who earned a doctorate in molecular biology before becoming a Buddhist monk.
When a healthcare leader, faculty member, or serious student asks for the comprehensive single-volume reference on compassion as a topic worth taking seriously, Altruism is the answer. Matthieu Ricard's 850-page treatment, published in English translation in 2015, is the most thorough single-author treatment of altruism, compassion, and their place in human flourishing currently in print. It is also the cleanest available bridge between rigorous science and contemplative tradition, which makes it directly relevant to CompassionSolution.Org's insistence that both are necessary.
Ricard's biography is the most useful single explanation of why the book has the authority it has. He earned a doctorate in molecular genetics in Paris in 1972, working at the Pasteur Institute under François Jacob, before turning, on his own initiative, to the contemplative tradition. He has been a Buddhist monk for over fifty years. He is a long-term meditator who has been a research subject in the neuroscience-of-meditation studies that the field rests on. He is the longtime French interpreter for the Dalai Lama. He is also one of the founding figures of the Mind and Life Institute, the organization that has facilitated more dialogue between contemplative practitioners and Western scientists than any other.
The book draws on all of this. It is comprehensive in a way that few books on this topic are. It addresses evolutionary biology, neuroscience, developmental psychology, social psychology, ethics, philosophy, economics, and political theory. It addresses the emergence of altruism in evolutionary terms, the biological substrate for compassion in neural terms, the developmental trajectory of empathy and compassion in childhood, the conditions under which compassion is sustained or eroded, the philosophical history of altruism in Western and Eastern traditions, and the contemporary economic and political case for altruism as a guiding principle. The scope is unusual. The depth at each level is also unusual.
Three contributions that bear directly on CompassionSolution.Org
The first contribution is the comprehensive scope. The reference book CompassionSolution.Org's faculty audience has been waiting for is Altruism. A faculty member designing a curriculum on compassion in healthcare can use the book as a structural reference for the territory the curriculum will cover. The Doctoral Scholarly Project's literature review owes much of its conceptual structure to this kind of comprehensive synthesis. Altruism is the closest single source to that structure available in print.
The second contribution is the science-and-tradition bridge done by an author who has lived inside both. Most books that try this either favor the science and treat the tradition as illustration, or favor the tradition and treat the science as ornament. Ricard does neither. The contemplative tradition is presented with the seriousness of someone who has practiced it for fifty years. The science is presented with the seriousness of someone who earned a doctorate in molecular genetics before turning to it. The two are integrated, not juxtaposed, and the reader leaves the book with a coherent picture rather than a contested one.
The third contribution is the rigorous treatment of the confusions the field is prone to. Pseudo-altruism, where helping behavior masks self-interest. Idiot compassion, where indiscriminate kindness produces harm. Compassion fatigue, which the contemporary literature is now recognizing as a confusion between compassion and empathic distress. Ricard addresses each of these confusions thoroughly, and his treatment is among the more useful in the literature for CompassionSolution.Org's argument that empathy and compassion are mechanistically distinct.
What the book does not do
The book is 850 pages and not a casual read. The reader who picks it up looking for a quick summary will be defeated. The book is best read as a reference, with specific chapters consulted as questions arise, rather than as a single sustained reading.
The book also draws on French and continental philosophical and economic context that some North American clinical readers may find unfamiliar. This is a feature of the book's scope, not a defect, but it does mean that some sections require more concentrated attention than others.
The book pre-dates some of the most recent compassion-training research, much of which has accumulated since 2015. It remains useful as a comprehensive foundation but is not the place to look for the newest empirical findings. The newer empirical literature in CompassionSolution.Org's reference library should be read alongside it.
Where to put it on the shelf
For any faculty member, advanced student, healthcare executive, or serious practitioner who wants the single most comprehensive reference on compassion currently available, Altruism is the answer. The book is the reference shelf in a single volume.
It pairs naturally with the entire foundational library: with Compassionomics and Wonder Drug for the medical evidence, with The Happiness Track and Self-Compassion for the practitioner-facing introductions, with Awakening Compassion at Work and The Power of Mattering for the leadership applications, and with A Fearless Heart and Into the Magic Shop for the contemplative-tradition lineage. The book is, in a sense, the volume the others have been writing chapters of.
Care differently, not less.
References
- Ricard, M. (2015). Altruism: The power of compassion to change yourself and the world. Little, Brown and Company.
- Klimecki, O. M., Leiberg, S., Lamm, C., & Singer, T. (2013). Functional neural plasticity and associated changes in positive affect after compassion training. Cerebral Cortex, 23(7), 1552-1561.
- Singer, T., & Klimecki, O. M. (2014). Empathy and compassion. Current Biology, 24(18), R875-R878.
- Goetz, J. L., Keltner, D., & Simon-Thomas, E. (2010). Compassion: An evolutionary analysis and empirical review. Psychological Bulletin, 136(3), 351-374.
- Doty, J. R. (2016). Into the magic shop: A neurosurgeon's quest to discover the mysteries of the brain and the secrets of the heart. Avery.